I.
Title: Which Bleach is the Most Effective Germ Killer for the Dollar.
Recommended Grade Level(s): 9-10
Subject(s): Integrated Science and Biology
Author: Dennis Zielinski
School: Ellsworth Senior High
II.
Objective: Students will collect data via titration of various
bleach and ink solutions as evaluation tools to identify which bleach will be
the most cost effective, along with being the best germ killer.
State Standards Met:
A.12.2
A.12.6
C.12.3
C.12.6
D.12.6
G.12.3
H.12.6
III
Equipment:
2- 10 ml graduate cylinders
2- Pipettes(Beryl or Eye droppers)
3-Test tubes
1-Test tube rack
3 x 5 index card
1.0 ml sample(s) of various bleaches
(diluted- 1 part bleach to 19 parts of water)
1.0 ml sample of washable blue ink
(diluted- 1 part ink to 19 parts of water)
Distilled water
Goggles
IV
Procedure:
1. Fill one of the graduate cylinders with exactly 5.0 ml of water.
2. Using one of the bleach pipettes, count the number of drops it takes
to raise the
level of the water from 5.0 to 6.0 ml.
3. Record this value in the data table. Make sure students hold
the pipette straight,
not on a slant, while dropping the bleach into the
cylinder.
4. Label this cylinder “Bleach”.
5. Repeat steps 1-4, except this time use the second cylinder and count
the number of
drops of ink needed to raise the level of water from
5.0 to 6.0 ml.
Then record this value in the table as well, and label this
cylinder “Ink”.
6. Using the “Bleach” pipette transfer exactly 1.0 ml of bleach from
the “Bleach”
cylinder to one of the test tubes.
7. Fill the “Ink” pipette with “Ink” from the second cylinder.
8. From your “Ink” pipette, slowly add the ink drop by drop into the
bleach test tube.
Gently shake the tube after each drop, and count each
drop added.
9. Students will be looking for a bluish colored endpoint. This
color may be faint,
so they must proceed carefully. The color
change will start out brown and go to
the blue color.
10. Record this number of drops in the table.
11. Repeat the experiment at least two more times
*
Calculations:
1. Convert the average number of drops of ink into volume(ml) of ink
used.
2. Calculate the volume of bleach that will react with 100 ml of ink.
To compare dif-
ferent bleaches, standardize the volumes of ink used.
Use the following ratios:
no. of ml of ink/1.0 ml of bleach to 100ml of
ink/X ml of bleach.
3. Calculate the cost of bleach/milliliter. Do this by dividing
the bottle volume in ml
by price in cents.
4. Calculate the cost-effectiveness of the bleach. Multiply
calculation 2 by calcula-
tion 3.
V. Assessment
Upon completion of this lab, the class will have data for several kinds of
bleach. The students should then seek out data from each other. I
would expect them to write and explanation/essay describing which brand of
bleach was the most cost effective, and they should site with data as support
for their answer. Since changing the color of the ink is oxidation, it
should be noted that killing germs is the same process. Therefore at the
same time have students identify which brand would be the most effective germ
killer.